Abstract

For developing color difference formulas, there are several choices to be made on the psychophysical method used for gathering visual (observer) data. We tested three different psychophysical methods: gray scales, constant stimuli, and two-alternative forced choice (2AFC). Our results show that when using gray scales or constant stimuli, assessments of color differences are biased toward lightness differences. This bias is particularly strong in LCD monitor experiments, and also present when using physical paint samples. No such bias is found when using 2AFC. In that case, however, observer responses are affected by other factors that are not accounted for by current color difference formulas. For accurate prediction of relative color differences, our results show, in agreement with other works, that modern color difference formulas do not perform well. We also investigated if the use of digital images as presented on LCD displays is a good alternative to using physical samples. Our results indicate that there are systematic differences between these two media.

© 2015 Optical Society of America

How color difference formulas depend on reference pairs in the underlying constant stimuli experiment

Eric Kirchner, Niels Dekker, Marcel Lucassen, Lan Njo, Ivo van der Lans, Pim Koeckhoven, Philipp Urban, and Rafael Huertas
J. Opt. Soc. Am. A 32(12) 2373-2383 (2015)

Color-difference formula for evaluating color pairs with no separation: ΔE_NS

Fereshteh Mirjalili, Ming Ronnier Luo, Guihua Cui, and Jan Morovic
J. Opt. Soc. Am. A 36(5) 789-799 (2019)

Analyzing small suprathreshold differences of LCD-generated colors

Philipp Urban, Maria Fedutina, and Ingmar Lissner
J. Opt. Soc. Am. A 28(7) 1500-1512 (2011)

Performance of select color-difference formulas in the blue region

R. Shamey, R. Cao, T. Tomasino, S. S. H. Zaidy, K. Iqbal, J. Lin, and S. G. Lee
J. Opt. Soc. Am. A 31(6) 1328-1336 (2014)

Investigations of suprathreshold color-difference tolerances with different visual scales and different perceptual correlates using CRT colors

Zhehong Wang and Haisong Xu
J. Opt. Soc. Am. A 25(12) 2908-2917 (2008)