Correct consideration of the index of refraction using blackbody radiation

doi:10.1364/OE.14.008121

« Show journal navigation

Correct consideration of the index of refraction using blackbody radiation

Jurgen Hartmann »View Author Affiliations

Optics Express, Vol. 14, Issue 18, pp. 8121-8126 (2006)
http://dx.doi.org/10.1364/OE.14.008121

View Full Text Article

Acrobat PDF (94 KB)

Journal Search
Article Lookup

Article Tools

Citations

Alert me when this article is cited
Export Citation/Save

Article Navigation

▸ Article Outline
– Abstract
1. Introduction
2. Consideration of the index of refraction for blackbody radiation
3. Discussion
– References and links

Article Tools
Full Text
Article Info
References
Cited By
Figures
Metrics
Download PDF

Viewing Equations in the
HTML Article

Optimal Viewing Recommendations

Full Text
Article Info
References (11)
Cited By
Figures (2)
Metrics

Abstract

The correct consideration of the index of refraction when using blackbody radiators as standard sources for optical radiation is derived and discussed. It is shown that simply using the index of refraction of air at laboratory conditions is not sufficient. A combination of the index of refraction of the media used inside the blackbody radiator and for the optical path between blackbody and detector has to be used instead. A worst case approximation for the introduced error when neglecting these effects is presented, showing that the error is below 0.1 % for wavelengths above 200 nm. Nevertheless, for the determination of the spectral radiance for the purpose of radiation temperature measurements the correct consideration of the refractive index is mandatory. The worst case estimation reveals that the introduced error in temperature at a blackbody temperature of 3000 °C can be as high as 400 mk at a wavelength of 650 nm and even higher at longer wavelengths.

1. Introduction

In optical measurements the index of refraction of the medium the optical radiation is penetrating has to be considered. Especially in the case were the optical radiation passes different media this fact is of high concern, as also refraction at the contact surface between the two media has to be considered. Working at usual laboratory conditions, the medium the radiation is penetrating is ambient air and the formulas for the index of refraction of air derived by Edlén and modified by others can be used to calculate the refractive index with low uncertainty [1

B. Edlén , “ The refractive index of air ,” Metrologia 2 , 71 – 80 ( 1966 ). [CrossRef]

, 2

K. P. Birch and M. J. Downs , “ An updated Edlén equation for the refractive index of air ,” Metrologia 30 , 155 – 162 ( 1993 ). [CrossRef]

, 3

R. Muijlwijk , “ Update of the Edlén formulae for the refractive index of air ,” Metrologia 25 , 189 ( 1988 ). [CrossRef]

, 4

K. P. Birch and M. J. Downs , “ Correction to the updated Edlén equation for the refractive index of air ,” Metrologia 31 , 315 – 316 ( 1994 ) [CrossRef]

, 5

G BÖnsch and E Potulski , “ Measurement of the refractive index of air and comparison with modified Edlén’s formulae ,” Metrologia 35 , 133 – 139 ( 1998 ). [CrossRef]

]. However, the situation is more complex when dealing with the measurement of blackbody radiation generated in a cavity radiator. Due to the different temperature inside and outside the blackbody cavity and due to purging of the cavity with argon or other inert gases, the index of refraction of the media inside and outside the blackbody cavity are, in general, different. In literature usually simply the index of refraction of ambient air is taken into consideration, accounting for the optical path between the opening of the cavity and the detecting instrument. For standard reference laboratory conditions the refractive index of ambient air is shown in Fig. 1 [2

K. P. Birch and M. J. Downs , “ An updated Edlén equation for the refractive index of air ,” Metrologia 30 , 155 – 162 ( 1993 ). [CrossRef]

]. However, this accounts only for the travelling part of the optical radiation outside the cavity, neglecting all effects originating inside the cavity. In some radiometric and photometric experiments reported in literature the refractive index is even neither stated nor considered at all.

Fig. 1. Refractive index of air a 1013 hPa, 0.03 % CO2 content and 50 % relative humidity.

For the generation of the blackbody radiation inside the cavity the index of refraction of the medium inside the cavity has to be taken into account [6

T. Quinn , Temperature , 2 ^nd ed., ( Academic Press, London 1990 ).

] and this might differ significantly from the value of the ambient medium, especially if the blackbody cavity is at elevated temperatures or purged by an inert gas.

2. Consideration of the index of refraction for blackbody radiation

Planck’s formula for the spectral radiance L _s,ν of a blackbody emitted per unit area and frequency interval in a solid angle is given as a function of frequency ν as [6

T. Quinn , Temperature , 2 ^nd ed., ( Academic Press, London 1990 ).

]

L_{s, ν} = \frac{\frac{2 h n^{2}}{c^{2}} ν^{3}}{\exp (\frac{hν}{kT}) - 1} .

(1)

In Eq. (1), n is the index of refraction of the medium inside the cavity at the cavity temperature T, ν is the frequency of the optical radiation, h is Planck’s constant, k is the Boltzmann constant and c the velocity of light in vacuum. For optical radiation inside a medium with refractive index n the following equation for the wavelength λ, the velocity of light in the medium c_n and the frequency ν holds

c_{n} = \frac{c}{n} = νλ,

(2)

resulting in

ν = \frac{c}{nλ}

(3)

Rewriting Eq. (1) as a function of wavelength λ inside the medium requires a relation for L _s,λ and L _s,ν. This can be found by using Eq. (3) resulting in the following expression

L_{s, ν} = \frac{d L_{s}}{dν} = \frac{d L_{s}}{dλ} ∣ \frac{dλ}{dν} ∣ = L_{s, ν} ∣ \frac{dλ}{dν} ∣, i . e L_{s, λ} = L_{s, ν} ∣ \frac{dν}{dλ} ∣ with

∣ \frac{dν}{dλ} ∣ = \frac{c}{n λ^{2}} .

(4)

Using Eq. (4) and Eq. (3), Eq. (1) can be written as follows

L_{s, λ} = \frac{\frac{2 h n^{2} c^{3}}{c^{2} n^{3} λ^{3}} ∣ \frac{dν}{dλ} ∣}{\exp (\frac{hc}{k nλ T}) - 1} = \frac{\frac{2 hc}{n λ^{3}} (\frac{c}{n λ^{2}})}{\exp (\frac{hc}{k nλ T}) - 1} = \frac{\frac{2 h c^{2}}{n^{2} λ^{5}}}{\exp (\frac{hc}{k nλ T}) - 1} .

(5)

Equation (5) describes the spectral radiance at the exit aperture of a cavity radiator containing a medium with refractive index n inside as a function of the wavelength λ inside this medium. Equation (5) is identical to the results given in literature [6

T. Quinn , Temperature , 2 ^nd ed., ( Academic Press, London 1990 ).

The radiation emitted by the opening of the blackbody cavity has to travel the distance between the exit aperture and the detector through the ambient medium, usually air at ambient conditions. This will cause a wavelength shift according to the index of refraction of the ambient medium, n _amb. To account for this, Eq. (5) is rewritten in terms of vacuum wavelength λ₀ = n·λ resulting in

L_{s, λ_{0}} = \frac{\frac{2 h c^{2}}{n^{2} \frac{λ_{o}^{5}}{n^{5}}}}{\exp (\frac{hc}{k n \frac{λ_{0}}{n} T}) - 1} = \frac{\frac{2 h n^{3} c^{2}}{λ_{0}^{5}}}{\exp (\frac{hc}{k λ_{0} T}) - 1} .

(6)

Accounting for the wavelength shift in the ambient medium requires replacement of λ₀ by n _amb·λ

L_{s, λ} = \frac{\frac{2 h n^{3} c^{2}}{n_{amb}^{5} λ_{o}^{5}}}{\exp (\frac{hc}{k n_{amb} λT}) - 1} = \frac{\frac{2 h c^{2}}{n_{amb}^{2} \frac{n_{amb}^{3}}{n^{3}} λ^{5}}}{\exp (\frac{hc}{k n_{amb} λT}) - 1} .

(7)

Comparing Eq. (7) with Eq. (5) reveals that the effect of including the transmission of the radiation through the ambient medium with refractive index n _amb introduced the factor (n/n_amb )³, changing the effective spectral radiance L _s,λ by this factor.

Another effect which has to be accounted for is the reflection occurring at the contact area between the media inside of the blackbody cavity and the outside media, usually ambient air. For perpendicular incidence the corresponding reflectivity R is

R = {(\frac{n_{amb} - n}{n_{amb} + n})}^{2} .

(8)

In Eq. (8) it is assumed that the transition between the two media inside and outside the blackbody is abrupt. However, in reality, as it is a transition between two gaseous phases, the transition is not abrupt but smooth and diffuse, therefore, Eq. (8) is an upper limit for the expected reflectivity. As the two media inside and outside the blackbody cavity are usually both gases the reflectivity at the contact between these two media will be negligible small. Therefore, Eq. (8) as a worst case assumption will be used for the purpose of this letter.

Consideration of Eq. (8) leads to the final formula for the spectral radiance emitted by a blackbody radiator at temperature T with a medium of refractive index n into a medium of refractive index n_amb

L_{s, λ} = [1 - {(\frac{n_{amb} - n}{n_{amb} + n})}^{2}] \frac{n^{3}}{n_{amb}^{3}} \frac{\frac{2 h c^{2}}{n_{amb}^{2} λ^{5}}}{\exp (\frac{hc}{k n_{amb} λT}) - 1} = a (n_{amb}, n) \frac{\frac{2 h c^{2}}{n_{amb}^{2} λ^{5}}}{\exp (\frac{hc}{k n_{amb} λT}) - 1}

(9)

with the factor

a (n_{amb}, n) = [1 - {(\frac{n_{amb} - n}{n_{amb} + n})}^{2}] \frac{n^{3}}{n_{amb}^{3}},

which accounts for the effect of the two different media inside and outside the blackbody cavity. For the correct consideration the factor a(n_amb , n) has to be taken into account, when calculating the spectral radiance emitted by a blackbody radiator according Planck’s law.

3. Discussion

For an estimation of the error introduced by simply using Eq. (5) with the refractive index of the ambient medium instead of using Eq. (9) calculations have been performed. The most pronounced effect is expected, if the refractive index inside and outside the blackbody cavity differs significantly. This will be the case for blackbodies at elevated temperatures. Usually such blackbodies are operated in an argon gas atmosphere [7

V. I. Sapritsky , B. B. Khlevnoy , V. B. Khromchenko , B. E. Lisiansky , S. N. Mekhontsev , U. A. Melenevsky , S. P. Morozova , A. V. Prokhorov , L. N. Samoilov , V. I. Shapoval , K. A. Sudarev , and M. F. Zelener , “ Precision blackbody sources for radiometric standards ,” Appl. Opt. 36 , 5403 – 5408 ( 1997 ). [CrossRef] [PubMed]

]. As the refractive index will approach unity for highest gas temperatures, for a worst case estimation it is assumed that the refractive index of the argon gas inside a blackbody cavity at temperatures of 3000 °C is unity. Using the modified Edlén equation for the refractive index of air as the outside medium given in Ref. 2 the relative difference (i.e. the ratio of the difference of a value a and a value b with respect to the value a) between Eq. (9), considering the two different media inside and outside the blackbody cavity correctly, and Eq. (5), considering only the refractive index of ambient air, has been calculated. The resulting relative difference as a function of wavelength is shown in Fig. 2.

Fig. 2. Relative difference (solid line) between the spectral radiance of a blackbody radiator with the correct consideration of the medium with refractive index of unity inside and of ambient air outside [according Eq. (9)] with respect to the spectral radiance only considering the refractive index of the ambient air [according Eq. (5)]. Also shown is the resulting error (dashed line) in determining the radiance temperature of a blackbody at 3000 °C (a) overview, b) detail at short wavelengths; the arrow in the graphics indicates that the right ordinate is valid for the dashed line while the left ordinate is valid for the solid line).

Figure 2 shows that neglecting the difference in refractive index inside and outside the cavity will introduce a nearly constant relative difference of about 0.08 % over the whole wavelength range from 200 nm to 15 μm, which is theoretically increasing to 0.1 % at wavelengths down to 100 nm, well within the vacuum ultraviolet regime. This error neglecting the different refractive indices might be tolerable in some photometric experiments, however it has to be taken into account for accurate radiance temperature measurements. The introduced error in determining the temperature of a blackbody at 3000 °C using radiometric methods is also shown in Fig. 2. In this worst case estimation this error is in the order of several tenths of a Kelvin in the visible, increasing to several Kelvin in the infrared region. In literature it is stated that the obtained uncertainty in radiometric temperature measurements nowadays is as low as a few tenths of a Kelvin for temperatures around 3000 °C [8

H. W. Yoon , C. E. Gibson , and J. L. Gardner , “ Spectral radiance comparison of two blackbodies with temperatures determined using absolute detectors and ITS-90 techniques ,” in Temperature: Its Measurement and Control in Science and Industry , D C Ripple , ed., ( AIP, New York , 2003 ) Vol. 7 , pp. 601 – 606 .

, 9

K. Anhalt , J. Hartmann , D. Lowe , G. Machin , M. Sadli , and Y. Yamada , “ Thermodynamic temperature determinations of Co-C, Pd-C, Pt-C and Ru-C eutectic fixed-points cells ,” Metrologia 43 , S 78 –S 83 ( 2006 ). [CrossRef]

, 10

J. Hollandt , R. Friedrich , B. Gutschwager , D. Taubert , and J. Hartmann , “ High-accuracy radiation thermometry at the National Metrology Institute of Germany, the PTB ,” High Temperatures - High Pressures 35/36 , 379 – 415 ( 2005 ). [CrossRef]

]. The correct consideration of the refractive index is, therefore, mandatory for radiometric temperature measurements. This is especially important for the determination of the thermodynamic phase transition temperatures of the novel metal-carbon and metalcarbide-carbon eutectics for an improved International Temperature Scale, where an uncertainty in temperature of about 0.1 K is required [11

Y. Yamada , “ Advances in high-temperature standards above 1000 °C ,” J. Metrol. Soc. India (India) 20 , 183 – 191 ( 2005 ).

Acknowledgment

The author would like to thank Howard Yoon from the National Institute for Standards and Technology and Peter Sperfeld from the Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt for bringing this problem to his attention. Fruitful discussion with Klaus Anhalt, Dieter Taubert, and JÖrg Hollandt from the Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt is also acknowledged.

References and links

1.	B. Edlén , “ The refractive index of air ,” Metrologia 2 , 71 – 80 ( 1966 ). [CrossRef]
2.	K. P. Birch and M. J. Downs , “ An updated Edlén equation for the refractive index of air ,” Metrologia 30 , 155 – 162 ( 1993 ). [CrossRef]
3.	R. Muijlwijk , “ Update of the Edlén formulae for the refractive index of air ,” Metrologia 25 , 189 ( 1988 ). [CrossRef]
4.	K. P. Birch and M. J. Downs , “ Correction to the updated Edlén equation for the refractive index of air ,” Metrologia 31 , 315 – 316 ( 1994 ) [CrossRef]
5.	G BÖnsch and E Potulski , “ Measurement of the refractive index of air and comparison with modified Edlén’s formulae ,” Metrologia 35 , 133 – 139 ( 1998 ). [CrossRef]
6.	T. Quinn , Temperature , 2 ^nd ed., ( Academic Press, London 1990 ).
7.	V. I. Sapritsky , B. B. Khlevnoy , V. B. Khromchenko , B. E. Lisiansky , S. N. Mekhontsev , U. A. Melenevsky , S. P. Morozova , A. V. Prokhorov , L. N. Samoilov , V. I. Shapoval , K. A. Sudarev , and M. F. Zelener , “ Precision blackbody sources for radiometric standards ,” Appl. Opt. 36 , 5403 – 5408 ( 1997 ). [CrossRef] [PubMed]
8.	H. W. Yoon , C. E. Gibson , and J. L. Gardner , “ Spectral radiance comparison of two blackbodies with temperatures determined using absolute detectors and ITS-90 techniques ,” in Temperature: Its Measurement and Control in Science and Industry , D C Ripple , ed., ( AIP, New York , 2003 ) Vol. 7 , pp. 601 – 606 .
9.	K. Anhalt , J. Hartmann , D. Lowe , G. Machin , M. Sadli , and Y. Yamada , “ Thermodynamic temperature determinations of Co-C, Pd-C, Pt-C and Ru-C eutectic fixed-points cells ,” Metrologia 43 , S 78 –S 83 ( 2006 ). [CrossRef]
10.	J. Hollandt , R. Friedrich , B. Gutschwager , D. Taubert , and J. Hartmann , “ High-accuracy radiation thermometry at the National Metrology Institute of Germany, the PTB ,” High Temperatures - High Pressures 35/36 , 379 – 415 ( 2005 ). [CrossRef]
11.	Y. Yamada , “ Advances in high-temperature standards above 1000 °C ,” J. Metrol. Soc. India (India) 20 , 183 – 191 ( 2005 ).

OCIS Codes
(120.3940) Instrumentation, measurement, and metrology : Metrology
(120.5240) Instrumentation, measurement, and metrology : Photometry
(120.5630) Instrumentation, measurement, and metrology : Radiometry
(120.6780) Instrumentation, measurement, and metrology : Temperature
(350.4800) Other areas of optics : Optical standards and testing
(350.5610) Other areas of optics : Radiation

ToC Category:
Instrumentation, Measurement, and Metrology

History
Original Manuscript: July 3, 2006
Revised Manuscript: August 9, 2006
Manuscript Accepted: August 12, 2006
Published: September 1, 2006

Citation
Jurgen Hartmann, "Correct consideration of the index of refraction using blackbody radiation," Opt. Express 14, 8121-8126 (2006)
http://www.opticsinfobase.org/oe/abstract.cfm?URI=oe-14-18-8121

Sort: Author | Year | Journal | Reset

References

B. Edlén, "The refractive index of air," Metrologia 2, 71-80 (1966). [CrossRef]
K. P. Birch and M. J. Downs, "An updated Edlén equation for the refractive index of air," Metrologia 30, 155-162 (1993). [CrossRef]
R. Muijlwijk, "Update of the Edlén formulae for the refractive index of air," Metrologia 25, 189 (1988). [CrossRef]
K. P. Birch and M. J. Downs, "Correction to the updated Edlén equation for the refractive index of air," Metrologia 31, 315-316 (1994) [CrossRef]
G Bönsch, and E Potulski, "Measurement of the refractive index of air and comparison with modified Edlén's formulae," Metrologia 35, 133-139 (1998). [CrossRef]
T. Quinn, Temperature, 2nd ed., (Academic Press, London 1990).
V. I. Sapritsky, B. B. Khlevnoy, V. B. Khromchenko, B. E. Lisiansky, S. N. Mekhontsev, U. A. Melenevsky, S. P. Morozova, A. V. Prokhorov, L. N. Samoilov, V. I. Shapoval, K. A. Sudarev and M. F. Zelener, "Precision blackbody sources for radiometric standards," Appl. Opt. 36, 5403-5408 (1997). [CrossRef] [PubMed]
H. W. Yoon, C. E. Gibson, and J. L. Gardner, "Spectral radiance comparison of two blackbodies with temperatures determined using absolute detectors and ITS-90 techniques," in Temperature: Its Measurement and Control in Science and Industry, D C Ripple, ed., (AIP, New York, 2003) Vol. 7, pp. 601-606.
K. Anhalt, J. Hartmann, D. Lowe, G. Machin, M. Sadli, and Y. Yamada, "Thermodynamic temperature determinations of Co-C, Pd-C, Pt-C and Ru-C eutectic fixed-points cells," Metrologia 43, S78-S83 (2006). [CrossRef]
J. Hollandt, R. Friedrich, B. Gutschwager, D. Taubert, and J. Hartmann, "High-accuracy radiation thermometry at the National Metrology Institute of Germany, the PTB," High Temperatures - High Pressures 35/36, 379-415 (2005). [CrossRef]
Y. Yamada, "Advances in high-temperature standards above 1000 °C," J. Metrol. Soc. India (India) 20, 183-191 (2005).

Appl. Opt.

V. I. Sapritsky, B. B. Khlevnoy, V. B. Khromchenko, B. E. Lisiansky, S. N. Mekhontsev, U. A. Melenevsky, S. P. Morozova, A. V. Prokhorov, L. N. Samoilov, V. I. Shapoval, K. A. Sudarev and M. F. Zelener, "Precision blackbody sources for radiometric standards," Appl. Opt. 36, 5403-5408 (1997). [CrossRef] [PubMed]

J. Metrol. Soc. India (India)

Y. Yamada, "Advances in high-temperature standards above 1000 °C," J. Metrol. Soc. India (India) 20, 183-191 (2005).

Metrologia

K. Anhalt, J. Hartmann, D. Lowe, G. Machin, M. Sadli, and Y. Yamada, "Thermodynamic temperature determinations of Co-C, Pd-C, Pt-C and Ru-C eutectic fixed-points cells," Metrologia 43, S78-S83 (2006). [CrossRef]
B. Edlén, "The refractive index of air," Metrologia 2, 71-80 (1966). [CrossRef]
K. P. Birch and M. J. Downs, "An updated Edlén equation for the refractive index of air," Metrologia 30, 155-162 (1993). [CrossRef]
R. Muijlwijk, "Update of the Edlén formulae for the refractive index of air," Metrologia 25, 189 (1988). [CrossRef]
K. P. Birch and M. J. Downs, "Correction to the updated Edlén equation for the refractive index of air," Metrologia 31, 315-316 (1994) [CrossRef]
G Bönsch, and E Potulski, "Measurement of the refractive index of air and comparison with modified Edlén's formulae," Metrologia 35, 133-139 (1998). [CrossRef]

Other

T. Quinn, Temperature, 2nd ed., (Academic Press, London 1990).
J. Hollandt, R. Friedrich, B. Gutschwager, D. Taubert, and J. Hartmann, "High-accuracy radiation thermometry at the National Metrology Institute of Germany, the PTB," High Temperatures - High Pressures 35/36, 379-415 (2005). [CrossRef]
H. W. Yoon, C. E. Gibson, and J. L. Gardner, "Spectral radiance comparison of two blackbodies with temperatures determined using absolute detectors and ITS-90 techniques," in Temperature: Its Measurement and Control in Science and Industry, D C Ripple, ed., (AIP, New York, 2003) Vol. 7, pp. 601-606.

Cited By

Alert me when this paper is cited

OSA is able to provide readers links to articles that cite this paper by participating in CrossRef's Cited-By Linking service. CrossRef includes content from more than 3000 publishers and societies. In addition to listing OSA journal articles that cite this paper, citing articles from other participating publishers will also be listed.

Click here to see a list of articles that cite this paper