1. Introduction
Microwave photonic links have been studied extensively due to their growing applications at high frequencies in commercial and defense communications such as CATV, antenna remoting, avionics, synthetic aperture radar, phased array antenna etc [
1C. Cox, Analog Optical Links , (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U.K., 2004).
,
2W. S. C. Chang, RF photonic technology in optical fiber links , (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U.K., 2002).
]. Radio frequency (RF) photonics is attractive for both transmission and signal processing. RF signal processing applications such as channelizing receivers provide the opportunity for optics to transform the challenging task of wideband spectral processing at high frequencies in the RF domain to narrowband processing in the optical domain with reduced complexity.
The utility of analog links depends upon various parameters including link gain, noise figure, bandwidth, and link linearity or dynamic range. High dynamic range is key to achieving high fidelity analog links and places highly challenging requirements on the components and the design of the system. The linearity of the link can be characterized by the spurious free dynamic range (SFDR) and is primarily dependent on the modulation and detection scheme. Both intensity modulation using direct detection and phase modulation using either direct detection or coherent detection have been studied. All these links exhibit a nonlinear transfer function and are thus limited in their linearity. Besides modulation and detection, the characteristic of the nonlinearity also depends on whether the link employs filtering.
Both optical and electronic methods to extend the dynamic range have been proposed and demonstrated. Electronic methods involve electronic predistortion [
3
M. Nazarathy, J. Berger, A. J. Ley, I. M. Levi, and Y. Kagan, “Progress in externally modulated AM CATV transmission systems,” J. Lightwave Technol.
11(1), 82–105 (1993). [CrossRef]
] while optical methods include cascaded modulators for predistortion [
4
G. E. Betts, “Linearized modulator for suboctave-bandpass optical analog links,” IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech.
42(12), 2642–2649 (1994). [CrossRef]
,
5
L. M. Johnson and H. V. Roussell, “Reduction of intermodulation distortion in interferometric optical modulators,” Opt. Lett.
13(10), 928–930 (1988). [CrossRef]
[PubMed]
], optical spectrum shaping [
6J. Zhang, and T. E. Darcie, “Two-tone analysis of distortion suppression in microwave photonic links using phase modulation and fiber-Bragg grating filters,” International Symposium on Signals, Systems and Electronics, Montreal, Quebec, 2007.
], optical phase locked loops (PLL) [
7
A. Ramaswamy, L. A. Johansson, J. Klamkin, H.-F. Chou, C. Sheldon, M. J. Rodwell, L. A. Coldren, and J. E. Bowers, “Integrated coherent receivers for high-linearity microwave photonic links,” J. Lightwave Technol.
26(1), 209–216 (2008). [CrossRef]
], and coherent post-processing [
8
T. R. Clark and M. L. Dennis, “Coherent optical phase modulation link,” IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett.
19(16), 1206–1208 (2007). [CrossRef]
]. Significant reduction in the intermodulation distortion has been achieved using these methods. Predistortion techniques require knowledge of the nonlinearity and may employ adaptive circuits to track changes in the input signal. Post-processing methods are extensively used in applications such as software defined radio (SDR). However, the post-processing methods such as an electro-optical PLL demonstrated so far rely on having access to the entire modulated signal in order to compensate for link nonlinearity and reconstruct the original transmitted signal.
In this paper we consider a filtered microwave photonic link useful for signal processing applications where the RF signal and the optical IF signal have the same bandwidth. We present an exact analytical solution for the transfer function of a phase-modulated passband filtered analog photonic link using balanced coherent detection. Of note is that this analysis is valid for both small and large passband RF signals. We present experimental time domain results from a two-tone test that confirms this analysis. Based on knowledge of the generic transfer function we present predistortion and post-processing techniques for linearization even when only a single sideband of the modulated signal band is accessible at the receiver.
2. Quadrature signals
Many RF waveforms that might be subjected to optical signal processing can be characterized by a center frequency
ωRF
and a bandwidth Δ. Such passband signals can be expressed in terms of an RF carrier and two quadrature components
x(
t) and
y(
t) as
Information is carried by the quadrature modulation components. The quadrature components for some common waveforms are listed in
Table 1
.
Table 1 Quadrature representation of some common RF waveforms
| SIGNAL
|
x(t)
|
y(t)
|
|---|
| SINGLE SIDEBAND |
x(t) |
|
| FREQUENCY SHIFT | cos(ωmt) | sin(ωmt) |
| DOUBLE SIDEBAND |
x(t) | 0 |
| TWO-TONE TEST | 2cos(ωmt) | 0 |
| PSK | cosθ (t) | sinθ (t) |
| QAM |
A(t) cosθ (t) |
A(t) sinθ (t)
|
The two tone signal is a simple double sideband waveform that is often used to characterize intermodulation distortion. The quadrature components of
z(
t) can also be expressed as
and
. An alternative representation of the bandpass signal is therefore
The amplitudes are related by
. It should be noted that this is more than a simple polar representation since
may take on a negative value. The two tone signal is one such example discussed below
3. Link description and transfer function
Figure 1
illustrates an optically-filtered phase-modulated analog photonic system considered in this paper. The output of a continuous wave (cw) laser at optical frequency Ω is split between the signal and the local oscillator (LO) paths. The signal path is phase modulated by an RF signal
z(
t) centered at frequency
ωRF
, while the LO path is phase modulated by a sinusoidal signal at frequency
ωLO
. Along with the fundamental optical frequency numerous sideband frequency components are generated. These are the harmonics and intermodulation frequencies. The intermodulation frequencies are within the fundamental signal band and arise when the input RF signal consists of more than one frequency component. This occurs in the signal path, which is phase modulated with
z(
t). Of these the third-order intermodulation distortion (TOI) is often dominant and limits the dynamic range. As shown in
Fig. 1, the two phase modulated signals are combined and then optically filtered to reject the higher order harmonics. The bandwidth of the optical filter is 2Δ in order to retain just the first upper sideband of both the signals. At the receiver the LO signal is used to coherently downconvert to an intermediate frequency (IF) of (
ωRF – ωLO
) resulting in the signal
S(
t) after balanced detection. We derive the expression for the recovered signal
S(
t) in this E/O/E link.
Fig. 1 Optically filtered analog photonic link.
The passband signal
z(
t) expressed in terms of its two quadrature components
x(
t) and
y(
t) is given by
Eq. (1).
The electrical field of the optical signal phase modulated with
z(
t) is given by
Where
is the phase modulator gain.
Vπ
is the voltage required for a π phase shift. Substituting
Eq. (2) in
Eq. (3), the middle term can be expanded as a Bessel series
where
is the k-th order Bessel function of the first-kind.
The optical filter rejects all components except the first upper sideband, for example. The filtered RF optical signal is coherently demodulated. The recovered signal
S(
t) following coherent balanced detection with the LO optical signal is given by
It is also possible to expand the phase modulation term in
Eq. (3) explicitly in terms of the quadrature components
x(
t) and
y(
t). This leads to the product of two Bessel series in
and
using
Keeping all of the terms that contribute to the upper optical sideband, one would arrive at the expression
One can see that
Eq. (8) is completely equivalent to
Eq. (5) using the Gegenbauer summation formula [
9I. S. Gradshteyn, and I. M. Ryzhik, Table of Integral Series and Products , (Academic Press, San Diego, Calif., 1994), pp. 979.
]:
The phase modulated filtered response of the E/O/E link again reduces to the simple form given by
Eq. (5).
Equation (5) gives the transfer function of the filtered phase-modulated link and shows that he recovered signal is a frequency translated and distorted version of the input RF signal. The amplitude modulation in
Eq. (5) (or
Eq. (9)) is given by
and takes on both positive and negative values. From
Eq. (5) the distortion can be described by
This demonstrates that filtered phase-modulation produces envelope distortion. The envelope distortion depends on
, which is positive valued and is independent of the phase
ϑ(
t).
The above analysis is valid for any kind of a passband signal z(t). Next we apply it to two simpler cases of the RF modulating signal z(t): single-tone and two-tone.
3.1 Case 1: Single-tone signal –invariance to frequency shift
We first consider the case when the modulating signal
z(
t) is a pure single-tone at frequency
which can expressed as
where
is the signal amplitude. The recovered signal
S(
t) after optical filtering given by
Eq. (5) (with
ρ(
t) =
x
0) is simply shifted in frequency by
with a constant amplitude
: there are no higher-order intermodulation terms, as expected.
3.2 Case 2: Two-tone signal – verify classical result
We next consider the simple two-tone signal with frequencies
. As noted in
Table 1, z
(
t) in this case can be written as
It is evident that
and
, for which
Eq. (5) gives
The signal amplitude can be expanded using the Gegenbauer summation theorem to give
This indicates that the recovered signal
S(
t) is centered around the IF (
ωRF – ωLO
) and consists of infinite frequency components at odd harmonics of
. The fundamental is obtained at frequency (
ωRF – ωLO
) ±
ωm
and has a magnitude
J1
(
βx
0)
J0
(
βx
0), while the third-order intermodulation distortion at frequency (
ωRF – ωLO
) ± 3
ωm
has a magnitude of
J2
(
βx
0)
J1
(
βx
0). These conclusions agree with the theory of two-tone signals well-known in literature.
4. Linearization techniques and experimental results
Distortion in passband filtered phase-modulated links appears as envelope distortion and can be mitigated either through feedforward correction which requires precise signal tracking or through post-compensation. In both cases the compensation response depends on the signal envelope rather than the carrier phase.
Using the link transfer function given by
Eq. (5) we can readily implement predistortion or post-processing techniques for linearization. In predistortion the nonlinearity is compensated by pre-multiplying the RF modulating signal or the optical LO with the inverse of the nonlinearity.
Using post-processing, the distortion, produced by
J
1(
βρ(t)), can be corrected when
ρ(
t) is estimated from the observed waveform. One can determine
ρ(
t) from measurements of
S(
t) within the region where the slope of
J
1(
βρ(t)) is nonzero using traditional digital signal processing (DSP) methods. Next we present experimental results on linearization based on post-processing. Experimental results on predistortion envelope compensation will be presented in a future publication. Furthermore, we have developed a novel technique based on multiscale sampling [
10A. Agarwal, T. Banwell, J. Jackel, P. Toliver, and T. K. Woodward, “Multiscale Sampling for Wide Dynamic Range Electro-optic Receivers,” Optical Fiber Communication , (Optical Society of America, San Diego, USA, 2009), OMI3.
] to extend the inversion region beyond where the slope vanishes.
4.1 Experimental results
The experimental setup for a filtered E/O/E link with two-tones as the input RF modulating signal
z(
t) is very similar to
Fig. 1. The two-tones at frequencies 4.999 GHz and 5.001 GHz with
ωm
= 1 MHz are passively combined and then amplified. The LO RF signal is at
ωLO
= 5.055 GHz. The output power of a 1550nm laser with a linewidth of 100 KHz is input to a dual arm MZM. A narrow linewidth laser is essential to ensure that the noise floor is limited by shot noise rather than laser phase noise and phase noise decorrelated by narrow band optical filtering. One arm of the MZM is used for phase modulating the two-tone RF signal and the other arm is used for modulating the LO signal. This allows these two phase modulated signals to be coherently combined after which a narrowband filter with a 3-dB bandwidth of 350 MHz filters the upper sideband fundamental around 5 GHz. A bias is applied to the RF signal arm to suppress the strong optical carrier by more than 25dB. The filtered output is coherently detected resulting in the recovered signal
S(
t) around an IF
ωIF
= 55 MHz. This signal consists of the fundamental two tones (at
ωIF
±
ωm
) along with the intermodulation distortion terms of which the third-order (at
ωIF
± 3
ωm
) is dominant.
Figure 2(a)
shows the experimental time-domain recovered signal recorded at 5GSa/s using the Agilent 54853A real-time scope (8-bit resolution without averaging and 2.5 GHz bandwidth) for a high RF input power of 18.5 dBm and shows pronounced distortion.
Equation (13) is fit to this data along with the envelope given by
J
1(2
β x
0cos(
ωmt)), showing excellent agreement and confirming the analysis derived above. This waveform will require multiscale sampling to invert the Bessel function and more details are found in reference [
10A. Agarwal, T. Banwell, J. Jackel, P. Toliver, and T. K. Woodward, “Multiscale Sampling for Wide Dynamic Range Electro-optic Receivers,” Optical Fiber Communication , (Optical Society of America, San Diego, USA, 2009), OMI3.
].
Fig. 2 Two-tone experimental data (a) Time-domain waveform along with a fit of the envelope. (b) Fundamental and TOI before and after post-processing.
The recovered passband signal envelope is slowly varying relative to
ωIF
. The desired signal is given by
ρ(
t)sin(
ωIFt +
θ) and can be reconstructed from measurements using
where
, with
A1
as a constant and
w(t) as a low-pass window function over one cycle of the IF carrier. Finally
ρ(
t) is reconstructed using
The Bessel function is inverted using
for │
x│ ≤ 0.5.
The IF output power of the fundamental and TOI are plotted as a function of the input RF power in
Fig. 2 (b). The resulting fundamental and TOI after post-processing to correct the envelope distortion are also shown. It is seen that envelope distortion compensation significantly suppresses TOI by ~20dB. The improvement is limited by ADC resolution, numerical accuracy, higher order terms, and other sources of distortion, most prominently the RF amplifier distortion. Note that the post-compensation is less effective for high input RF powers (for example > 9dBm) as the inversion of the Bessel function is not accurate. Multiscale sampling would help to relieve this problem and thus extend the inversion region.
Note that in addition to the suppression of TOI, the overall link linearity is also dependent on the link noise and bandwidth. This has been discussed in many of the referenced articles and in this paper we have focused on the suppression of TOI.
5. Summary
We have presented an analytical solution for the large signal transfer function of optically-filtered analog photonic systems such as those encountered in optical processing of RF signals. This solution is valid for arbitrary passband RF signals. It was shown that in filtered phase-modulated links the distortion appears as envelope distortion and can be compensated through predistortion and post-processing techniques that show promise for achieving high performance RF photonic links.